← All issues
Caravaggio in Rome
SECRETS SERVICE
Special issue · 2024Travel · Photo · Stories
Special issue · Rome

Caravaggio in Rome

12 May 2024, half past twelve. The church of the French, a couple of minutes from the Pantheon, a red rope, raised phones — and three paintings that made a painter from Lombardy the most famous artist in Rome in a single summer. Six years later he would run from this city with a death sentence on his head.

On the cover: The Calling of Saint Matthew, Contarelli Chapel · Hasselblad H6D-50C

Contarelli ChapelThree canvases of Saint Matthew
Swords and artichokesA genius with a police record
7 framesHasselblad H6D-50C

In this chapel the light falls twice: once from the window, once from the canvas.

Secrets Service · Special issue
Chapter I · San Luigi dei Francesi · 12 May 2024
I

A red rope
and raised phones

The national church of the French in Rome, the last chapel on the left by the altar — and a crowd that stands in silence.

The first thing you hear is not the paintings but the silence. In San Luigi dei Francesi, a couple of minutes’ walk from the Pantheon, there is a spot where a crowd stops talking on its own. The last chapel on the left, by the altar. A red rope, twenty people with their heads tilted back. Someone holds a phone up over other people’s shoulders. The camera clock says 12:27. It is the same May trip as issue No. 02.

Back then the light over the paintings ran on coins. You drop a euro into the box by the chapel, the canvases step out of the dark for a minute or two, then sink back. We fed it coins more than once. A strange feeling for a photographer: here you literally buy the light, a couple of minutes at a time.

This is the Contarelli Chapel. The name is the Italian form of Matthieu Cointrel, a French cardinal who died in 1585 and left money to decorate a chapel to his patron saint, the apostle Matthew. The project dragged on for almost fifteen years. Giuseppe Cesari, a fashionable painter of the day, had finished the vault by 1593, but the walls never got started.

On 23 July 1599 the contract went to a 27-year-old Lombard who until then had mostly painted small pictures for collectors — fortune tellers, cardsharps, boys with fruit. He lived next door, in Palazzo Madama, in the household of Cardinal Francesco Maria del Monte, who bought his work and, it seems, helped him land the commission. Palazzo Madama is now home to the Italian Senate. From its doors to the chapel is a couple of hundred steps.

It was Caravaggio’s first major public commission. He delivered in a year.

Contarelli Chapel, San Luigi dei Francesi
Contarelli Chapel, San Luigi dei Francesi. Hasselblad H6D-50C
Chapter II · The Calling and the Martyrdom · 1599–1600
II

A beam, a finger
and a sword

Two walls of the chapel. On the left, a man being called. On the right, a man being killed. Between them, a year of work and fame.

The left wall holds The Calling of Saint Matthew, a canvas 322 by 340 centimetres. A dark room, a table, tax men and young dandies in velvet and feathers counting coins. Christ enters from the right, almost entirely in shadow; you see little more than his hand. And a slanting beam of light that reaches the faces at the table before they understand what is happening.

Christ’s hand is an almost mirror image of Adam’s hand on the Sistine Chapel ceiling. Except that Adam receives life, while here life is being given: the tax collector Levi is called to a new one, as the apostle Matthew.

The right wall holds The Martyrdom of Saint Matthew, 323 by 343 centimetres. The largest canvas Caravaggio had ever painted, and he had never handled so many figures either. You can still see the struggle — but only in X-rays. Under the paint there are two earlier compositions: first a crowded one with plenty of architecture, as was the custom, then another with onlookers in the manner of Raphael. In the end he threw out nearly all the architecture and half the people. What remains is the executioner, the fallen old man, a boy running off screaming — and darkness.

In the background, to the left behind the executioner, a bearded man turns to look back at the killing. He is generally taken to be Caravaggio himself. He is 28, and he paints himself as a witness.

Both paintings were in place by July 1600. The reaction was immediate. Some attacked him for painting from life, as if straight off the street; others called him the one true imitator of nature. On one point they agreed: from that summer on, Caravaggio never lacked commissions or patrons.

The Martyrdom of Saint Matthew. Contarelli Chapel, San Luigi dei Francesi
The Martyrdom of Saint Matthew. Contarelli Chapel, San Luigi dei Francesi. Hasselblad H6D-50C
He did not invent his saints. He found them in the tavern next door — and put them under a beam of light.
Secrets Service
Chapter III · The altar · 1602
III

The Inspiration
they turned down

The chapel’s third painting is a second attempt. The first was lost in Berlin in 1945.

The altar was originally meant to have a sculpture. The Flemish sculptor Jacques Cobaert carved the apostle and failed to please — partly because there was no angel beside him, and Matthew the Evangelist was never shown without one. The statue was rejected, and in February 1602 the altarpiece went to Caravaggio. Deadline: Pentecost that same year.

The first version, Saint Matthew and the Angel, did not pass either. The clergy found it too crude: what stood over the altar was not an apostle but an actual peasant — heavy, plain, with the angel guiding his hand across the page like a teacher guiding a pupil’s. And this Matthew did not match the two on the walls.

The rejected canvas survived — for a while. It ended up in Berlin, in the Kaiser Friedrich Museum. During the war the pictures were stored in the flak tower at Friedrichshain, which was supposed to keep them safe from the bombs. In 1945, at the very end of the war, the tower burned. Saint Matthew and the Angel went up in flames with hundreds of other paintings. Only black-and-white photographs remain.

Caravaggio painted the second version, The Inspiration of Saint Matthew, quickly, and was paid in September 1602. Here the apostle wears a red cloak and has his dignity back; the angel no longer guides his hand but hovers above him, counting on his fingers, as if listing the genealogy of Christ with which Matthew’s Gospel opens. It is a compromise. But a Caravaggio compromise.

The Inspiration of Saint Matthew. Contarelli Chapel, San Luigi dei Francesi
The Inspiration of Saint Matthew. Contarelli Chapel, San Luigi dei Francesi. Hasselblad H6D-50C
Stories and facts · 1600–1610

Swords, artichokes
and a price on his head

Caravaggio’s life reads like a novel because the Roman police all but kept a file on him. In 1600, while living with del Monte, he beat one of the cardinal’s guests, the nobleman Girolamo Stampa, with a club. In 1603 he was arrested for libellous verses about the painter Giovanni Baglione. Between May and October 1604 he was arrested several times for carrying weapons without a licence and insulting the city guards.

And from the same year comes the story every biographer loves. A tavern waiter took Caravaggio to court after the painter threw a plate of artichokes in his face. This is not a legend; it is a court record.

On 29 May 1606 Caravaggio killed Ranuccio Tomassoni, a young man from a powerful family with a reputation as a thug. Nobody knows exactly what happened. According to the most popular version, the quarrel was over a bet on a game of pallacorda, an ancestor of tennis. It is also said that jealousy was involved — over the courtesan Fillide Melandroni, who sat for Caravaggio. Whether it was a duel or a street brawl, and whether he meant to kill, historians still argue.

The sentence was beheading. Caravaggio ran: Naples, then Malta, where Grand Master Alof de Wignacourt made him a knight. A few months later came another brawl, prison, an escape, and in December 1608 the Order expelled him as a “foul and rotten member”. Sicily. Naples again, where in October 1609 he was attacked and his face so badly cut that rumours of his death reached Rome.

In the summer of 1610 he sailed north towards Rome with paintings for Cardinal Scipione Borghese, hoping for a papal pardon. He never got there. On 18 July 1610 Caravaggio died at Porto Ercole, aged 38. The cause is still debated: fever, malaria, an infected wound, lead poisoning from his paints. There was whispering about murder too, of course — revenge by the Tomassoni or by the Knights of Malta. There is no proof.

Among his last paintings is David with the Head of Goliath. The giant’s severed head is a self-portrait. In The Martyrdom of Saint Matthew he painted himself as a witness. At the end, as the victim.

Chapter IV · An hour earlier · Santa Maria della Vittoria
IV

Light made
out of a window

The morning of the same day, two kilometres away — another genius, another kind of light.

EXIF does not lie: at 11:27, exactly an hour before the Contarelli Chapel, we were standing in another church, Santa Maria della Vittoria, in front of Gian Lorenzo Bernini’s Ecstasy of Saint Teresa.

Bernini was born in December 1598, just as Caravaggio was heading for his first big commission. When Caravaggio died, Bernini was eleven. He carved Teresa almost forty years later, in 1647–1652, for the burial chapel of the Venetian cardinal Federico Cornaro.

The scene comes from Saint Teresa of Ávila’s own autobiography: an angel with a golden spear, a little fire seeming to burn at its tip, and a pain that is at the same time bliss. On either side of the chapel, in marble boxes as if at the theatre, members of the Cornaro family sit and watch, like an audience.

The frames from that evening, at half past seven above the rooftops, are in black and white. Without colour, what is left is the one thing Rome learned from them both: light and shadow. The people in them are tourists from China — we never learned their names, but we emailed them the pictures afterwards.

Bernini’s Ecstasy of Saint Teresa. Cornaro Chapel, Santa Maria della Vittoria
Bernini’s Ecstasy of Saint Teresa. Cornaro Chapel, Santa Maria della Vittoria. Hasselblad H6D-50C
Tourists from China
Tourists from China. Probably the Pincio terrace · Hasselblad H6D-50C
Tourists from China
Tourists from China. Probably the Pincio terrace · Hasselblad H6D-50C
Caravaggio is very close to me — through light and shadow. I love his paintings just as I love Rembrandt’s.
Petr Kirichenko
Afterword · Lisbon

From Caravaggio’s light
to Rembrandt’s

For us Caravaggio is, above all, light. Not the stories, not the biography with its police reports, but the way a beam picks a face, a hand, a coin on a table out of the dark. A photographer works with the same material, only without a brush: choosing what to light and what to leave to the shadow. That is why you keep coming back to these paintings.

There is an odd rhyme between the two painters. On 29 May 1606 Caravaggio kills Tomassoni and flees Rome. On 15 July 1606 Rembrandt is born in Leiden. He never once set foot in Italy, but Caravaggio’s light reached Holland without him — through painters from Utrecht who had worked in Rome and brought the manner home. They are known, simply, as the Utrecht Caravaggisti.

To see Rembrandt from Lisbon, you do not have to go far. The Calouste Gulbenkian Museum has two paintings that once belonged to Catherine the Great. In 1930 Gulbenkian bought them from the Hermitage through Antikvariat, the Soviet agency that was selling off museum treasures.

The museum gives the Portrait of an Old Man, 1645, to Rembrandt without reservation. Pallas Athena, painted around 1657, is more complicated. Since 1991 scholars have doubted that the master painted it himself: at first it was given to a pupil, and the cautious view accepted today is Rembrandt together with a studio assistant. That is how the museum itself presents it. There is no agreement on the sitter either: Athena, Minerva, Mars or Alexander the Great. The light on the armour, though, is beyond dispute.

Contract
1599
23 July

Caravaggio signs for the Contarelli Chapel. He is 27.

The chapel
3
canvases of Matthew

The Calling and the Martyrdom by July 1600, the Inspiration in 1602.

Size
323 × 343
centimetres

The Martyrdom — the largest canvas he had painted so far.

Loss
1945
Berlin

The rejected first version, Saint Matthew and the Angel, burned in a flak tower.

Flight
1606
29 May

The killing of Ranuccio Tomassoni, a death sentence and four years on the run.

A life
38
years

Caravaggio died on 18 July 1610 at Porto Ercole, never having made it back to Rome.

Practically · Rome

How to see Caravaggio in the churches

San Luigi dei Francesi stands between the Pantheon and Piazza Navona, and entry is free. You cannot get near the chapel during Mass, and the church closes for a break during the day — check current hours on the church’s website. For years the light over the paintings was switched on by a coin box — it still was when we visited in May 2024. In January 2025 the five chapels of the left aisle got new lighting funded by the Bulgari Foundation, and according to the project description the coin box was removed. Bring a couple of euros just in case.

Three hundred metres away, the church of Sant’Agostino has Caravaggio’s Madonna di Loreto. Two more — the Conversion of Saint Paul and the Crucifixion of Saint Peter — hang in the Cerasi Chapel of Santa Maria del Popolo. David with the Head of Goliath is in the Galleria Borghese, which needs a timed ticket.

Santa Maria della Vittoria and Bernini are about two kilometres away on foot. For espresso at the bar, the Campo de’ Fiori market and the Roman evenings of the same trip, see issue No. 02. And for another painting people stand before in silence, see our special issue on Vermeer.

In Lisbon, the two Rembrandts from the former Hermitage collection hang in the permanent display of the Calouste Gulbenkian Museum. Opening hours and tickets are on the museum’s website.

You might also like
Rome 2024 № 02 Rome 2024 Vermeer Special issue Vermeer
More issues
All issues →